What Is Calypso’s Argument to Hermes When He Tells Her That She Must Let Odysseus Go?

Calypso’s Argument to Hermes When He Tells Her That She Must Let Odysseus Go

Calypso is a beautiful nymph who lives on the island of Ogygia. She is the daughter of Atlas and is known for her ability to enchant and seduce men.

In the epic poem, “The Odyssey,” Calypso detains Odysseus on her island for seven years and refuses to let him leave. When Hermes, the messenger god, comes to Calypso with Zeus’ command that she must release Odysseus, she protests vehemently. Let us take a closer look at Calypso’s argument to Hermes.

Calypso’s Plea for Love

Calypso argues that she has fallen in love with Odysseus and that they have been living together as husband and wife on her island. She says that they have shared everything together and that she has been a good companion to him during his time there. She pleads with Hermes not to take away the man she loves.

The Double Standard

Calypso points out a double standard that exists between gods and mortals. She argues that gods are free to do as they please, but mortals are always subject to the whims of the gods. She questions why Zeus can have any woman he wants but mortals cannot choose their own destiny.

The Unfairness of Life

Calypso argues that it is unfair for Odysseus to be punished for trying to return home after fighting in a war. She claims that he has suffered enough already and deserves some happiness in his life.

The Power of Love

Calypso believes that love conquers all and asks Hermes if he has ever been in love himself. She suggests that if he had, he would understand her situation better. Calypso believes that her love for Odysseus is stronger than the will of the gods.

The Injustice of the Patriarchal System

Calypso criticizes the patriarchal system of ancient Greece, where women are often treated as possessions. She argues that men have the power to do as they please, but women are always subject to their whims. She believes that she has a right to love and be loved just like any man.

In conclusion, Calypso’s argument to Hermes is a passionate plea for love and justice. She argues that her love for Odysseus should be enough to allow him to stay with her on Ogygia.

While her argument is compelling, it ultimately fails because she cannot overcome the power of Zeus’ command. Nevertheless, Calypso’s story remains a powerful reminder of the importance of love and compassion in our lives.